Electric cars

The war in Russia could further drive up auto prices and shortages

An e-Golf electric car with the VW logo on a rim is pictured in the German car manufacturer Volkswagen Transparent Factory in Dresden, eastern Germany, April 28, 2017. Russia's devastating war on Ukraine is bringing a whole set of new problems to the global auto industry.

An e-Golf electric car with the VW logo on a rim is pictured inside German carmaker Volkswagen’s transparent factory in Dresden, eastern Germany, April 28, 2017. Russia’s devastating war on the ukraine brings a whole host of new problems to the world automotive industry. (Jens Meyer, Associated Press)

Estimated reading time: 6-7 minutes

DETROIT — BMW has halted production at two German plants. Mercedes is slowing down work at its assembly plants. Volkswagen, warning of production stoppages, is looking for alternative sources for parts.

For more than a year, the global auto industry has been grappling with a disaster shortage of computer chips and other vital parts that have cut production, slowed deliveries and driven up prices for new and used cars beyond the reach of millions of consumers.

Now a new factor – Russia’s war against Ukraine – raised a new obstacle. Critically important electrical wiring, made in Ukraine, is suddenly out of reach. With strong buyer demand, scarcity of materials and war causing further disruption, vehicle prices are expected to rise further over the next year.

The damage of the war to the automotive industry first appeared in Europe. But U.S. production is also likely to suffer eventually if Russian exports of metals — palladium for catalytic converters nickel for electric vehicle batteries — are cut off.

“You only have to miss a part and you can’t make a car,” said Mark Wakefield, co-head of the global automotive unit at consultancy Alix Partners. “Any bump in the road becomes either a production disruption or a largely unforeseen cost increase.”

Supply issues have plagued automakers since the pandemic hit two years ago, sometimes closing factories and causing vehicle shortages. The robust post-recession recovery has caused demand for autos to far outstrip supply – a mismatch that has sent new and used vehicle prices skyrocketing well above high headline inflation. .

In the United States, the average price of a new vehicle has risen 13% over the past year, to $45,596, according to Edmunds.com. Average used prices rose much more: they rose 29% to $29,646 in February.

Before the war, S&P Global predicted that global automakers would build 84 million vehicles this year and 91 million next year. (By comparison, they built 94 million in 2018.) Now it projects less than 82 million in 2022 and 88 million next year.

It is enough to miss a part not to be able to manufacture a car.

–Mark Wakefield, Alix Partners Global Automotive Unit

Mark Fulthorpe, executive director of S&P, is among analysts who believe the availability of new vehicles in North America and Europe will remain extremely tight – and prices high – through 2023. To compound the problem, buyers who are overpriced new-vehicle market will intensify the demand for used cars and also keep these prices high, which will be prohibitive for many households.

Eventually, high economy-wide inflation—for food, gas, rent, and other necessities—will likely leave many ordinary buyers unable to afford a new vehicle or occasion. Demand would then decrease. And therefore, possibly, the prices.

“Until inflationary pressures start to really erode the capabilities of consumers and businesses,” Fulthorpe said, “it’s likely to mean those who fancy buying a new vehicle will be willing to pay top dollar.”

One of the factors behind the lower production outlook is the closure of car factories in Russia. Last week, French automaker Renault, one of the last automakers to continue building in Russia, announced it would suspend production in Moscow.

The transformation of Ukraine into a besieged war zone has also hurt. Wells Fargo estimates that 10-15% of the crucial wiring harnesses that power vehicle production in the vast European Union were made in Ukraine. Over the past decade, automakers and parts companies have invested in Ukrainian factories to contain costs and be closer to European factories.

The wiring shortage has slowed factories in Germany, Poland, the Czech Republic and elsewhere, leading S&P to cut its global auto production forecast by 2.6 million vehicles for this year and next. The shortages could reduce exports of German vehicles to the United States and elsewhere.

In this March 21 still image made from video, Mark Wakefield, co-head of AlixPartners' global automotive unit, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press at the company's offices. board in Southfield, Michigan.
In this March 21 still image made from video, Mark Wakefield, co-head of AlixPartners’ global automotive unit, speaks during an interview with The Associated Press at the company’s offices. council in Southfield, Michigan (Photo: Mike Householder, Associated Press)

Wiring harnesses are wire harnesses and connectors unique to each model; they cannot be easily transferred to another parts manufacturer. Despite the war, harness makers like Aptiv and Leoni have managed to sporadically reopen factories in western Ukraine. Still, Joseph Massaro, Aptiv’s CFO, acknowledged that Ukraine “isn’t open to any type of normal business activity.”

Dublin-based Aptiv is trying to move production to Poland, Romania, Serbia and possibly Morocco. But the process will take up to six weeks, leaving some automakers short of parts during that time.

“In the long term,” Massaro told analysts, “we will have to assess if and when it makes sense to return to Ukraine.”

BMW is trying to coordinate with its Ukrainian suppliers and casting a wider net for parts. Just like Mercedes and Volkswagen.

Yet finding alternative supplies can be nearly impossible. Most parts factories are running near full capacity, so a new workspace would have to be built. Companies would need months to hire more people and add shifts.

“The training process to upgrade a new workforce — it’s not an overnight thing,” Fulthorpe said.

Mercedes stars are displayed at the Daimler-Benz factory in Sindelfingen, southern Germany, February 1, 2011.
Mercedes stars are displayed at the Daimler-Benz factory in Sindelfingen, southern Germany, February 1, 2011. (Photo: Michael Latz, Associated Press)

Fulthorpe said it expects a further tightening in the supply of materials from Ukraine and Russia. Ukraine is the world’s largest exporter of neon, a gas used in lasers that etch circuits onto computer chips. Most chipmakers have a six-month supply; later in the year, they might run out. This would aggravate the shortage of chips, which before the war was delaying production even more than automakers anticipated.

Similarly, Russia is a key supplier of raw materials such as platinum and palladium, used in emission catalytic converters. Russia also produces 10% of the world’s nickel, an essential ingredient in electric vehicle batteries.

Mineral supplies from Russia have not yet been interrupted. Recycling could help alleviate the shortage. Other countries can increase their production. And some manufacturers have stocked the metals.

But Russia is also a major producer of aluminum and a source of pig iron, used to make steel. According to Alix Partners, nearly 70% of US pig iron imports come from Russia and Ukraine. Steelmakers will therefore have to switch to Brazilian production or use alternative materials. Meanwhile, steel prices have soared from $900 a ton a few weeks ago to $1,500 today.

So far, negotiations for a ceasefire in Ukraine have come to nothing and fighting has raged. A new virus outbreak in China could also reduce parts supply. Industry analysts say they have no clear idea when parts, raw materials and auto production will flow normally.

Even if an agreement is negotiated to suspend the fighting, the sanctions against Russian exports will remain intact until a final agreement is reached. Even then, supplies would not begin to flow normally. Fulthorpe said there would be “further hangovers due to the disruptions that will take place in widespread supply chains”.

Wakefield also noted that due to the intense pent-up demand for vehicles across the world, even if automakers restore full production, it will take a long time to build enough vehicles.

When could the world produce enough cars and trucks to meet demand and keep prices low?

Wakefield does not pretend to know.

“We are in a rising price environment, a constrained (production) environment,” he said. “It’s a strange thing for the auto industry.”


Related stories

Tom Krisher and Kelvin Chan

More stories that might interest you